Dr Philipp Simon – Investigating Carrot Colours to Produce Healthier Crops
Carrots display a wide range of different colours – orange, purple, white, red and yellow – driven by the accumulation of various compounds. These compounds affect the nutritional value and health benefits of the roots, making them prime targets for breeding better varieties. Dr Philipp Simon and his colleagues at the United States Department of Agriculture investigate the genetics of carrot colours to help breeders develop even more nutritious strains.
A Nutritious & Colourful Root
Versatile, tasty, and full of vitamins, carrots can be found in cuisines across the globe. And their popularity is rising – the number of carrots grown worldwide has quadrupled in the last few decades, with farmers currently producing more than 42 million tonnes every year.
However, the orange carrots we see at the supermarket are a comparatively recent variety. In fact, for most of history, farmers have been digging purple roots out of their fields. ‘Orange carrots were only first described around 500 years ago,’ notes Dr Philipp Simon, researcher at the United States Department of Agriculture. ‘Purple and yellow were the first colours, reported 1100 years ago. Red and white carrots have also been developed within the last several hundred years.’
The reason behind the widespread switch to orange carrots is still rather controversial. Many people claim that it was a political statement by Dutch farmers supporting the Prince of Orange, who led the struggle for Dutch independence. Others dismiss this as entertaining but factually unsupported. Regardless of the reason, the choice of colourful carrots was a rather fortunate one for humanity as a whole – many of the root’s health benefits can be traced back to these cheerful pigments. ‘Brightly coloured carrots are important for nutrition,’ explains Dr Simon. ‘The most important of these are the orange carotenoid compounds which are sources of vitamin A. The red, yellow, and purple pigments also provide key nutrients as antioxidants.’
This is excellent news for carrot lovers, but researchers are always interested in the ‘why’ behind facts. Why are carrots such excellent sources of these compounds? How are these compounds formed? And can we make carrots produce them in higher quantities?
Crop breeders are always seeking to develop healthier strains of fruit and vegetables, which have better nutritional value or contain higher levels of vitamins and antioxidants. For this reason, Dr Simon is bringing the many well-hidden secrets of carrot genetics into the light, to aid breeders in their quest to create highly nutritious varieties.
The Carrot Genome
The basis of this work comes from the carrot genome – its complete genetic code – which Dr Simon and his collaborators published in 2016. Determining a genome is no simple process; while genetic sequencing technology has advanced by leaps and bounds, we are still limited to ‘reading’ around 1000 letters of the genetic code at a time. For comparison, the length of the carrot genome is roughly 470 million ‘letters’ (or, more correctly, ‘base pairs’).
This means that any sequence has to be created from thousands of different ‘reads’, each of which need to be placed into context like jigsaw pieces. Specialised computer software and very expensive machines are required to gather this information and bring it together in the right way. Even with a wealth of knowledge behind them, problems can arise – for example, some parts of the genome are filled with repeated sequences, which makes it impossible to determine how they fit together. The carrot genome published by Dr Simon and his collaborators provided a map of around 90% of the complete genetic code – not perfect, but enough to make it one of the most complete genomes available.
From this basis, the researchers branched out into the world of carrot colours.
Food for Your Eyes
Carrots are one of the best dietary sources of a carotenoid compound called beta-carotene, which is converted into vitamin A in the human body. As vitamin A is vital for our vision, genetic processes, immune responses and skin health, carrots are an important part of a healthy diet.
Beta-carotene is a bright orange-red chemical, providing much of the bright orange colour we associate with carrots. Yet, as we’ve mentioned, orange carrots are themselves a fairly recent innovation. Why do they contain so much beta-carotene, and such a blazingly orange colour? What genetic changes happened across centuries of breeding to reach this point?
This is the sort of question that Dr Simon loves to investigate. ‘Carrot colours provide insights into the development and domestication of carrot as a root crop,’ he explains, ‘allowing better understanding of the molecular and biochemical mechanisms underlying carotenoid biosynthesis, and are useful for nutritionists to study pigments in whole foods.’
To improve this understanding, Dr Simon and his colleagues investigated the genomes of different carrot strains, ranging in colour from white through to bright orange. They demonstrated that orange colour was correlated to changes in a single area of the genome – one that contains 72 genes.
To narrow down this region further, the researchers performed transcriptome analysis, which indicates whether a gene is ‘on’ or ‘off’ – whether it is actively being used to create proteins or not. They showed that four genes have different activities at different stages in the carrot lifecycle, while another 13 exhibit different activity depending on the local conditions. With this as a basis, the team then examined 25 different carrot varieties, showing that the genetic sequence in that area is much more variable between orange strains than between white or yellow ones.
This is important for several reasons. First, the variability could be linked to beta-carotene levels – thus plant breeders could use particular genetic markers to determine if their new strains would be more or less orange. Second, the list of variable genes would then be the basis for further research, with in-depth studies discovering how precisely beta-carotene synthesis is controlled.
‘Carrot colours provide insights into the development and domestication of carrot as a root crop, allowing better understanding of the molecular and biochemical mechanisms underlying carotenoid biosynthesis, and are useful for nutritionists to study pigments in whole foods.’
The Or Gene
As previously mentioned, carrots are one of the best sources of carotenes in our diet. However, carrots have much higher carotene levels than we would expect, given what scientists know about the biochemical pathways involved.
Dr Simon and his collaborators looked at the genomes of many different wild and domesticated carrot varieties, looking for differences that might explain this. They were able to find a mutation within a single gene, known as the Or gene, which is never found in wild carrots but is almost always present in domestic varieties. The mutation leads to increased formation of chromoplasts – cellular compartments that produce and store coloured chemicals such as carotenes.
Interestingly, the team was also able to show that all Western domestic carrots are genetically very similar, despite the wide variety in colour and appearance. The mutant Or gene, with its beneficial impact on carotene levels, appears to have been an early trait that was selected when carrots were domesticated, many centuries ago.
Purple is the New Orange
While orange carrots contain large amounts of carotenoid compounds such as beta-carotene, purple carrots have very high concentrations of anthocyanins, which exhibit antioxidant and anti-inflammatory effects. Diets rich in anthocyanin-containing fruits and vegetables are associated with a reduced level of diabetes, heart disease, arthritis and even some cancers.
This is quite interesting for crop breeders, who are always seeking to develop strains with both additional health benefits and visual appeal. In order to do so, however, they need to understand the biochemical basis of the purple carrots – how are these anthocyanins generated, and how can we enhance their production?
This is where Dr Simon enters the picture once more. His team had previously looked into the genome of purple carrots and had shown that the genes for anthocyanin expression in the root and petiole (the stalk that attaches a leaf to the stem) could be narrowed down to a specific region of the genome. Further experiments narrowed this down even further, allowing the researchers to identify a cluster of transcription factors that control anthocyanin biosynthesis.
Transcription factors are a special form of protein, which control the expression of other genes. One transcription factor may turn a set of genes on in response to certain stimuli, while another may turn them off if a cellular signal comes in. In this way, the fixed ‘instructions’ present in the genome can be read in a specific, context-dependent manner.
In this case, a cluster of transcription factors belong to the MYB gene family are the main candidates for purple colouring in all carrots examined during the studies. Dr Simon and his colleagues demonstrated that these influence colouring in the roots and petioles, respectively, by controlling a number of other genes and biochemical processes that lead to anthocyanin accumulation.
The Carrot of the Future
So where will the researchers go from here? Dr Simon is interested in the development of new carrot strains that contain increased levels of beneficial nutrients such as carotenoids and anthocyanins. They are currently working with several experts in agriculture to bring these ideas to the market.
Beyond this, he is enthusiastic about the next steps for his research. ‘Sequencing of the carrot genome has significantly stimulated the development of high-pigment carrots,’ says Dr Simon, ‘and this story is only beginning to unfold!’
Meet the researcher
Dr Philipp W. Simon
USDA Vegetable Crops Research Unit
Dr Philipp Simon began his scientific studies with a PhD in Genetics from the University of Wisconsin, Madison in 1977. Since 1979, he has been working as a Research Geneticist, and since 1986 a Research Leader, in the Vegetable Crops Research Unit of the USDA Agricultural Research Service (USDA-ARS), and Professor of Horticulture at the University of Wisconsin, Madison. Over the course of his successful career, Dr Simon has published over 200 papers, trained more than 30 PhD students, and won a multitude of prestigious awards, including an Honorary Doctorate from the Agricultural University of Krakow, Poland, and the National Association of Plant Breeders Lifetime Achievement Award. His research in vegetable genetics and breeding focuses on fresh market carrot improvement, targeting improved flavour and nutritional quality, nematode, disease and abiotic stress resistance, and genetic mapping.
KEY RECENT COLLABORATORS
Pablo Cavagnaro, CONICET and INTA, Argentina
Julie Dawson, University of Wisconsin, Madison
Shelby Ellison, University of Wisconsin, Madison
Irwin Goldman, University of Wisconsin, Madison
Dariusz Grzebelus, University of Agriculture in Krakow, Poland
Massimo Iorizzo, North Carolina State University
Philip Roberts, University of California, Riverside
David Spooner, USDA-ARS, Madison
Sherry Tanumihardjo, University of Wisconsin, Madison
Allen Van Deynze, University of California, Davis
USDA, Agricultural Research Service
USDA, National Institute of Food and Agriculture
California Fresh Carrot Advisory Board
F Bannoud, S Ellison, M Paolinelli, T Horejsi, D Senalik, M Fanzone, M Iorizzo, P Simon, P Cavagnaro, Dissecting the Genetic Control of Root and Leaf Tissue-Specific Anthocyanin Pigmentation in Carrot (Daucus carota L.), Theoretical and Applied Genetics, 2019, 132, 2485–2507.
M Iorizzo, PF Cavagnaro, H Bostan, Y Zhao, J Zhang and PW Simon, A Cluster of MYB Transcription Factors Regulates Anthocyanin Biosynthesis in Carrot (Daucus carota L.) Root and Petiole, Frontiers in Plant Science, 2019, 9, 1927.
SL Ellison, CH Luby, KE Corak, KM Coe, D Senalik, M Iorizzo, IL Goldman, PW Simon and JC Dawson, Carotenoid Presence Is Associated with the Or Gene in Domesticated Carrot, Genetics, 2018, 210, 1497–1508.
S Ellison, D Senalik, H Bostan, M Iorizzo and P Simon, Fine Mapping, Transcriptome Analysis, and Marker Development for Y2, the Gene That Conditions b-Carotene Accumulation in Carrot (Daucus carota L.), Genes Genomics Genetics, 2017, 7, 2665–2675.
M Iorizzo, S Ellison, et al., A high-quality carrot genome assembly provides new insights into carotenoid accumulation and asterid genome evolution, Nature Genetics, 2016, 48, 657–666.
Creative Commons Licence
(CC BY 4.0)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
What does this mean?
Share: You can copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format
Adapt: You can change, and build upon the material for any purpose, even commercially.
Credit: You must give appropriate credit, provide a link to the license, and indicate if changes were made.
More articles you may like
Identifying the cause of an illness in a sick baby or child is not always easy, particularly if the disease is rare. Throughout his career, Dr Michael Wangler, at the Baylor College of Medicine and Jan and Dan Duncan Neurological Research Institute, has investigated rare childhood diseases. Combining his expertise in paediatrics and genetics, Dr Wangler utilises genomics, metabolomics and the humble fruit fly to identify the genes responsible for rare and undiagnosed diseases to improve both diagnosis and treatment.
Radiation therapy is an effective and widely used method of treating cancer, and as with any treatment, it is essential to get the right dose. However, Dr Stephen Kry from The University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center has found widespread errors in the systems that calculate the doses patients receive. Through his research, he has helped to identify where these errors occur, how common they are, and provide possible solutions. He hopes that his work will go on to improve the quality and efficacy of radiotherapy for many cancer patients.
Dr Peter Bretscher – A Substantiated Framework for the Prevention and Treatment of Immune System-Related Diseases
Immunity is generated normally against invaders, such as viruses and cancer cells, but not against parts of the body to which the immune system belongs. In 1970, Dr Peter Bretscher and Dr Melvin Cohn proposed a theory to account for how this is achieved. Importantly, immune responses against invaders can take one of two main forms, and Dr Bretscher (currently at the University of Saskatchewan) also proposed an explanation for how the choice of immunity is made. These two proposals are supported by diverse findings. Here, we outline and justify these proposals and explain how they lead to strategies to prevent and treat diverse diseases.
Dr Lakshmi Mahadevan – Mental Health First Aid: Bridging the Gap between Rural Communities and Access to Care
In the USA, poor mental health and opioid addiction are prominent and widespread. With a lack of understanding and resources in many rural areas in Texas, many people facing mental health and addiction challenges do not know where to turn. Dr Lakshmi Mahadevan at Texas A&M AgriLife Extension Service is helping to train up rural communities in Mental Health First Aid (MFHA) so that they can provide better care for those in need.