Dr Tewodros Rango Godebo – Using Innovative Technology to Investigate Bone Disorders Induced by Environmental Contaminants
Throughout the world, especially in low-income countries, environmental contaminants such as fluoride have huge health consequences. While some countries add fluoride to their drinking water, others have little control over its concentration, resulting in dangerously high fluoride concentrations. Excess fluoride exposure is known to cause the bone disease skeletal fluorosis, but Dr Tewodros Rango Godebo from Tulane University in Louisiana, USA, believes that current diagnosis techniques are incomplete. Using ultrasound technology, he has determined for the first time how fluoride exposure leads to reduced bone quality, and how this diagnosis can be used in fluoride-exposed populations.
Fluoride in Our Water and Our Bodies
Our bodies are constantly exposed to mixtures of chemicals in the surrounding environment. The levels of each often depend on location and local regulations, meaning some people experience toxic levels and are consequently at high risk for health complications.
One such element that humans frequently consume is the negative ion of fluorine, called fluoride. Although it is found naturally in varying amounts, in many areas, fluoride is added to drinking water to help reduce tooth decay and improve dental health. However, an excess of fluoride consumption is linked to a variety of disorders. For example, if a child’s teeth come into contact with too much fluoride while they are still developing, a condition called dental fluorosis may occur. Individuals with mild cases experience white marks on their teeth, whilst those with severe cases have discoloured and badly pitted enamel on the teeth surface. A severe form of enamel fluorosis is shown in Figure 1. This image is of a 14-year-old boy who grew up with 13mg/L of fluoride in drinking groundwater in the Ethiopian Rift Valley and who, as a result, experienced significant loss of enamel.
The skeletal system is most at risk for adverse effects resulting from fluoride over-consumption. Fluoride becomes incorporated into bone tissue which can cause a multitude of issues, depending on how much fluoride is ingested, how long an individual is exposed for and from what age, as well as genetic factors. For example, physiological processes can be disrupted, meaning the bone tissue is not maintained and repaired properly. This leads to a much higher risk of fractures and breakages. Even neurological development and functions of the reproductive system and cardiovascular system can be altered by the presence of excess fluoride.
This surplus fluoride in the body changes both the physical and chemical properties of the bone minerals and the bone and enamel cells. If an individual is exposed for a sustained period at high fluoride levels while their bones are growing or repairing, they are highly likely to develop a disease called chronic skeletal fluorosis. This issue is one focus of Dr Tewodros Godebo’s research at Tulane University in New Orleans, Louisiana. Serving as an Assistant Professor in the School of Public Health and Tropical Medicine, Dr Godebo studies long-lasting exposure to low- and high-fluoride and subsequent chronic skeletal fluorosis using novel diagnostic methods.
Chronic Skeletal Fluorosis
This chronic disease presents various bone complications and joint, tendon and ligament calcification that progressively worsen. This deposition of calcium crystals on the tissues that connect bone to muscle (tendons) and bone to bone around the joints (ligaments) leads to chronic pain and disabling movement in the long term. The hallmark of skeletal fluorosis is osteosclerosis – the thickening of tissue resulting in an abnormally thick bone. The disease also results in damage called bone lesions and osteoporosis which is the weakening of the bones.
Skeletal fluorosis also impacts the large, tightly bound molecules that help keep the bone tissue together, known as matrix proteins. Collagen is an example of one of these proteins, and when altered due to disease, the elasticity and biomechanical integrity of the bone is damaged. This means that people suffering from skeletal fluorosis have a very high tendency to suffer from fractures and breaks, which can be exacerbated by the effect of fluoride on the function of the parathyroid glands. This results in hyperparathyroidism, which means that the hormones that normally regulate the calcium concentration in the body are imbalanced. The consequent depletion of calcium in the bones further diminishes their flexibility and thus increases susceptibility to fractures.
The physical structure of bone tissue is complex as it includes an intricate network of mineralised fibrils, cells, proteins and water. The different bone parameters, from its density and collagen composition to the microstructures inside, all influence how resistant a bone is to fracture. These components come together to determine the mechanical properties of bone.
Therefore, even though it is well-understood how fluoride impacts bone forming and resorbing cells, it is unclear how it affects bone quality in humans. A skeletal fluorosis diagnosis still depends on using X-ray imaging to determine bone density. However, this method of testing does not account for alterations to the microstructures, collagen composition and elasticity due to fluoride exposure. This is where Dr Godebo is making strides in his field by investigating how innovative technology can be used to improve the diagnosis of chronic skeletal fluorosis.
An Ethiopian Population with High Exposure to Fluoride
In an important study, Dr Godebo and his colleagues analysed data from a population of 341 participants, aged 10–70 years old, living in the rural location of the Rift Valley in Ethiopia. Around 14 million of those living in Ethiopia are thought to be at high risk of dangerous levels of fluoride exposure. However, the Rift Valley region experiences an unusually high exposure to natural fluoride from the groundwater wells for which they depend on their drinking and cooking water.
A wide range of fluoride concentrations in the drinking water was found, spanning from 0.3 mg/L to 15.5 mg/L. To put this into context, the typical low level of fluoride in most high-income countries (including where it is added to prevent tooth decay) is 0.7 mg/L and the World Health Organization recommends that drinking water should not contain a fluoride concentration any higher than 1.5 mg/L. This means that shockingly, some people were ingesting ten times the recommended amount of fluoride. This was represented in urine samples from the participants which showed an unusually high concentration (up to 39.5 mg/L) of fluoride, suggesting a significant amount of fluoride is also retained in the bone.
The team used a non-invasive, portable ultrasound method to measure the bone density of the population in the first study of its kind. All the previously mentioned parameters of the bone quality (density, collagen and microstructure) affect the speed of sound (SOS) measurement. Because there was previously no existing research on using ultrasound and SOS to measure the bone quality in groups with varying levels of exposure to fluoride, Dr Godebo aimed to investigate how useful and applicable it could be in real-world situations.
Before beginning the experiment, Dr Godebo hypothesised that SOS would increase as bone density increased due to fluoride exposure. This is because the X-ray diagnosis technique that is used in countries where skeletal fluorosis is common tends to detect increased bone density (osteosclerosis) in these patients.
An Unexpected Finding
Dr Godebo measured the SOS in a type of bone tissue called cortical bone, which is a protective, dense outer surface layer of tissue that surrounds the internal cavity. It comprises nearly 80% of the skeleton and is dense and solid, making it a good target for measuring bone quality and strength. They tested the tibia in the lower leg, the radius in the forearm and phalanx in the fingers (see illustration above titled ‘Bone with osteoperosis’.
Intriguingly, Dr Godebo discovered that his initial hypothesis was incorrect and that higher fluoride exposure in fact decreased SOS measurements in all three of the cortical bone sites. This suggests that because ultrasound measurements are able to measure and characterise the overall quality and inner properties of the bone, these decreased measurements actually indicate the deterioration of the bone. According to Dr Godebo, this reveals that the physical effects of excessive fluoride exposure are complex and diverse, as is bone quality.
Most importantly, it was found that individuals sourcing their drinking water from community wells with elevated levels of fluoride had significantly lower bone quality compared to those from communities with low fluoride levels. Dr Godebo’s work has shown that this fluoride-induced bone deterioration can be confirmed and quantified in rural settings, outside of medical establishments. X-ray techniques are relatively expensive, they expose patients to potentially dangerous radiation, and are difficult or even impossible to use in remote settings. In comparison, Dr Godebo’s ultrasound method is portable, low-cost and effective. As such, the method would be useful for a widespread assessment of how fluoride and other environmental contaminants may harm bone health at the population level. However, it will be important to test the feasibility of this as a diagnostic method through additional research in clinical settings and other locations.
Dr Godebo’s research is a vital component of understanding how fluoride impacts the health and lives of people who have little control over their water source and how this might be investigated in the future. Furthermore, this work and methods have the potential to be applied to other environmental contaminants as well as other induced bone disorders.
MEET THE RESEARCHER
Dr Tewodros Rango Godebo
School of Public Health and Tropical Medicine
New Orleans, LA
Dr Tewodros Rango Godebo is an Assistant Professor at the Department of Environmental Health Sciences, School of Public Health and Tropical Medicine. He received his PhD in Environmental Geochemistry from Ferrara University, Italy. Prior to joining Tulane, he was a postdoctoral fellow in the Nicholas School of the Environment, Duke University. His research interests lie in identifying the origins and mechanisms of water-soil-food contamination, as well as utilising and developing elemental biomarkers to understand the links between exposure to contaminants and human health.
Environmental Geochemistry, Water and Food Quality, Biomarkers and Health
Biniyam A Ayele, Assistant Professor, Department of Neurology, Addis Ababa University, Ethiopia
Marc Jeuland, Associate Professor, Sanford School of Public Policy and the Duke Global Health Institute, Duke University, USA
Redda Tekle-Haimanot, Professor Emeritus, Department of Neurology, Addis Ababa University, Ethiopia
Gary M. Whitfield, Professor, Department of Oral Biology and Diagnostic Sciences, Augusta University, USA
US National Institutes of Health
TG Rango, MA Jeuland, R Tekle-Haimanot, et al., Bone quality in fluoride-exposed populations: A novel application of the ultrasonic method, Bone Reports, 2020, 12, 100235.
TG Rango, CJ Paul, MA Jeuland, R Tekle-Haimanot, Biomonitoring of metals and trace elements in urine of central Ethiopian populations, International Journal of Hygiene and Environmental Health, 2019, 222(3), 410–418.
TG Rango, A Vengosh, MA Jeuland, et al., Biomarkers of chronic fluoride exposure in groundwater in a highly exposed population, Science of the Total Environment, 2017, 596, 1–11.
REPUBLISH OUR ARTICLES
We encourage all formats of sharing and republishing of our articles. Whether you want to host on your website, publication or blog, we welcome this. Find out more
Creative Commons Licence (CC BY 4.0)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
What does this mean?
Share: You can copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format
Adapt: You can change, and build upon the material for any purpose, even commercially.
Credit: You must give appropriate credit, provide a link to the license, and indicate if changes were made.
MORE ARTICLES YOU MAY LIKE
Worldwide, an estimated 38 million people are living with HIV. Many are still unaware of their status and so are not linked to care and treatment which can prevent them from passing HIV onto their partners and infants and keep them healthy. Dr Richard Hayes from the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine in the UK has led the HIV Prevention Trials Network’s 071 (PopART) trial over the past ten years. This dedicated international collaboration of experts has successfully demonstrated how universal testing and treatment can reduce new HIV infections in Zambia, South Africa and beyond.
Scoliosis, the curving of the spine, is a relatively common condition that develops in early adolescence. Whilst there are surgical options to neutralise the curve, there is no solid evidence for its long-term impact. Dr Hans-Rudolf Weiss is an expert in scoliosis treatments and has dedicated his research to improving the care of scoliosis patients. Through his back brace innovations and novel exercise therapies, he has developed ground-breaking new standards of care for patients. Additionally, through his Schroth Best Practice program, he is educating a new generation of doctors and physiotherapists on his non-surgical methods.
Professor Arthur Grollman | Professor Francis Johnson – Kidney Disease and Urinary Tract Cancer: How a Traditional Medicinal Plant Causes Serious Health Issues
This is a recounting of a scientific investigation into a mysterious but potentially deadly disease that first came to light principally in the Balkan states, and then several Asian countries. It manifests itself first as a nephropathy resulting in the destruction of kidney tissue often followed by a cancer of the upper urothelial tract. Professors Arthur Grollman and Francis Johnson at Stony Brook University have achieved a revolutionary understanding of the molecular biology, epidemiology and root cause of both diseases. Their findings have critical implications for medical and scientific communities, as well as the general public.
Dr Vanessa van Ast from the University of Amsterdam in the Netherlands is driving forward understanding of how and why our emotional memories change over time. As well as elucidating how our memories of specific events and emotions influence behaviour, her most recent work is unveiling the impact that different contexts may have on the storage and recall of memories.