Dr Anushia Inthiran | Distance Learning: Impacts for Offshore Students Amid COVID-19
The COVID-19 pandemic significantly disrupted global education and necessitated a shift to online learning. Due to ongoing border closures, even after the pandemic eased, offshore students were prevented from attending their university in person long after their local peers, impacting their learning ability and future perspectives. Dr Anushia Inthiran from the University of Canterbury conducted a survey among a group of offshore students to understand the consequences of distance learning on their education.
COVID-19 and Higher Education
The COVID-19 pandemic had wide-reaching impacts, and the education realm was no exception. Within higher education institutions, information and communication technology became a vital lifeline as universities implemented ‘education in emergency’ strategies. These included online teaching and remote learning. However, while blended learning – the incorporation of online learning activities in addition to face-to-face teaching – has long been a part of education, this sudden and complete switch to online approaches required rapid adaptations to teaching methods.
This dramatic modification had consequences not only on teaching and learning but also on the health and wellbeing of staff and students. However, the students arguably most affected are those referred to as ‘offshore students’, that is, international students enrolled online at a university, as opposed to receiving in-person tuition. The advent of the pandemic enforced widespread border closures, meaning many of these students had never stepped foot on their university’s campus, creating detachment from a typical university setting.
As the pandemic progressed and lower alert levels ensued, many students were able to return to campus. However, national borders were still closed, preventing offshore students from doing the same. This development was thought to beget further feelings of isolation among the offshore students, necessitating additional support to remain engaged.
Surveying Offshore Students
Dr Anushia Inthiran from the University of Canterbury explored the experiences of ‘new offshore students’ at a New Zealand university – a term coined to describe those who had never set foot on campus. Her pilot study, the first of its kind, assessed the impact on learning and wellbeing. A questionnaire was developed by Dr Inthiran to assess various aspects of their experience and distributed to 20 students. It received a 75% completion rate, the results of which were analysed both quantitatively (i.e., numerically) and qualitatively (i.e., descriptively).
In order to encourage participants to answer freely, open-ended questions were used, which followed four broad topics of enquiry, namely: (i) how new offshore students felt not having visited their university campus, (ii) what strategies they used to engage with teaching and learning material, (iii) the teaching strategies used by staff to engage offshore students, and (iv) feedback on strategies the teaching and learning team could have used to better engage offshore students. Multiple questions were posed in each broad topic.
Illuminating ‘Invisible’ Students
Survey responses revealed high levels of negative emotion among new offshore students. Responses to the question of how they felt about their situation were categorised into distinct emotional categories: (i) miserable and depressed, (ii) frustrated, (iii) upset, (iv) missing out, and (v) regret. Most responses fell into the ‘miserable and depressed’ category and included responses such as ‘I will Graduate in my room’ and ‘I feel left behind, better to have enrolled in local university’.
A related question addressed how students might suggest mitigations to these negative effects, and responses included both positive and negative suggestions. Positive responses detailed how they were able to self-motivate and make the most of personal hobbies. Negative responses evoked a ‘grin and bear it’ attitude.
Live Zoom tutorials and communication with peers were preferred for learning, while recorded and live lectures were less effective due to limited interaction and inclusivity from lecturers. Offshore students recorded that 53% of communication from staff was via email, with a further 23% taking the form of drop-in Zoom sessions. When asked to assess their effectiveness, 40% of the offshore students considered these to be effective, while 60% either disagreed or were unsure.
Dr Inthiran’s analysis suggests that many frustrations among new offshore students stem from feeling ‘invisible’. She highlights a misalignment between the services provided by universities and students’ perceptions, noting that specialised programmes developed for offshore students may not be effectively communicated and, therefore, utilised. For example, services such as online mentoring were established, but it is unknown if the targeted students were even aware of such services.
Furthermore, it appears the teaching and learning team did not fully utilise available methods of communication, such as an offshore discussion board and student Zoom sessions. This is evidenced by email being the dominant communication strategy, which is likely reflected in the 60% of students who were not sure or did not think that the strategies were effective in engaging them with teaching material.
On the basis of her findings, Dr Inthiran highlights potential factors that impact learning and suggests potential remedies. For instance, she notes that the difficulty experienced by new offshore students in creating bonds with and trust in their lecturers arose from not being able to ‘see’ them during lectures. Suggestions such as turning on videos while teaching, acknowledging their presence during lectures, and conducting Zoom tutorials would help foster a more inclusive learning environment for offshore students.
Shining Light on Barriers Facing Offshore Students
While Dr Inthiran acknowledges limitations to her study, such as a small sample size, her research highlights important issues faced by new offshore students and offers mitigations to such concerns, as suggested by the students themselves.
Her future work aims to involve students who are not just new offshore students but general offshore students who had previously attended their university in person, but were blocked from returning to New Zealand after border closure was enforced by pandemic restrictions. Her student-centric focus will inevitably lead to improved outcomes. By providing such students with a voice in academic literature, her work shines a light on barriers facing offshore students in their right to access high-quality education from their institution.
SHARE
DOWNLOAD E-BOOK
REFERENCE
https://doi.org/10.33548/SCIENTIA1021
MEET THE RESEARCHER
Dr Anushia Inthiran
Department of Accounting and Information Systems
UC Business School
University of Canterbury
Christchurch
New Zealand
Dr Anushia Inthiran earned her Bachelor of Computing from Monash University in 1999 and her Master of Science in Technology Management from Staffordshire University in 2006. Her PhD from Monash University in 2013 focused on Medical Information Searching, and in the same year, she became the primary investigator on a grant from the Ministry of Education. She then obtained a Graduate Certificate in Higher Education from Monash University in 2015. Since 2017, she has served as a Senior Lecturer at the University of Canterbury, later becoming Senior Lecturer above the bar in 2021. Dr Inthiran’s research interests span from human-computer interactions to health informatics. She is recognised for her significant contributions to the field. Her dedication to education is evident through her leveraging her expertise to act both as a lecturer and as a mentor to graduate students, for which she was awarded the Student Choice award for Postgraduate Supervisor of the Year by the University of Canterbury Student Association in 2021 and the Citation for Outstanding Contribution to Student Learning in 2016 whilst at Monash University.
CONTACT
E: anushia.inthiran@canterbury.ac.nz
W: https://profiles.canterbury.ac.nz/Anushia-Inthiran
FURTHER READING
A Inthiran, I am Offshore! Teaching and Learning in the Time of a Pandemic: A Pilot Study, Interchange, 2023, 54, 301–315. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10780-023-09498-4
R Sharma, K Jones, W Anderson, et al., The Digital Disruption of Higher Education– “uni for nothin’, MOOCs for free”?, Journal of Information Technology Case and Application Research, 2022, 24(1), 34–60. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/15228053.2021.1889741
R Sharma, K Jones, W Anderson, A Inthiran, Higher Education 4.0: Uni for nothin’, MOOCs for free?, International Conference on Information Systems (ICIS), 2019, Munich, Germany.
REPUBLISH OUR ARTICLES
We encourage all formats of sharing and republishing of our articles. Whether you want to host on your website, publication or blog, we welcome this. Find out more
Creative Commons Licence (CC BY 4.0)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
What does this mean?
Share: You can copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format
Adapt: You can change, and build upon the material for any purpose, even commercially.
Credit: You must give appropriate credit, provide a link to the license, and indicate if changes were made.
SUBSCRIBE NOW
Follow Us
MORE ARTICLES YOU MAY LIKE
Michael Y Schakelaar | Hybrid PhDs: Integrating Biomedical and Educational Research
Biomedical science-based PhDs are often research-focused, designed to hone a candidate’s expertise in a specific field. However, subsequent careers in university settings frequently entail substantial teaching responsibilities, with PhD graduates unprepared for the dual roles of researcher and educator. Hybrid PhDs aim to better equip graduates for academic careers by integrating highly specialised scientific knowledge with educational research. PhD candidate Michael Y Schakelaar of University Medical Center Utrecht (Utrecht University), The Netherlands, provides an outstanding example of how this can be achieved.
Dr Alexandra Babino | Bilingual Education: Nurturing Language Skills and Cultural Identity in Latino Students
Bilingual education programmes aim to help students develop proficiency in multiple languages while learning grade-level content. However, the reality is often more complex, especially for Latino students navigating between Spanish and English in the USA. Dr Alexandra Babino from Texas Woman’s University explores how these students develop their language skills and identities in bilingual educational settings. Her research provides valuable insights to help educators nurture students’ multilingual abilities and cultural connections.
Dr Jo Boaler | Transforming Mathematics Education Through Mindset-Based Teaching
Mathematics education in the United States has long struggled with issues of underachievement and inequity. Despite decades of reform efforts, many students continue to struggle with math, developing negative attitudes and beliefs about their own mathematical abilities. However, recent research into mindset and brain plasticity offers promising new directions for transforming how mathematics is taught and learned. A groundbreaking study led by Dr Jo Boaler at Stanford University demonstrates how a ‘mathematical mindset’ approach to teaching can dramatically improve student achievement and engagement, even in just a few weeks of instruction.
Dr Kimberly Coy | Virtual Schooling: How Digital Education Can Increase Inclusivity
Virtual schooling – teaching conducted entirely online – has become increasingly important since the COVID-19 pandemic. Even prior to the pandemic, virtual schools were recognised for providing alternatives to students with needs beyond those catered for in traditional classroom settings. While research into the factors influencing the success of virtual schools is lacking, Dr Kimberly Coy of California State University, Fresno, is working to address this knowledge gap. She is particularly interested in the challenges facing the application of digital learning and strategies that may overcome these.