Dr Kyla Zatti | Aquaculture Feed: Progressing the Use of Algal Oils in Salmon
Salmon and other seafood represent a large and important food source. Traditionally, salmon diets consisted mainly of fish, although over the last decade, they have become more vegetable based. However, salmon require essential lipids, which are hard to find except in fish oil. Dr Kyla Zatti and a group of scientists at BioMar have been working to effectively bypass fish oil in their aquafeed by going to the original source of the lipids while maintaining the welfare, growth, and quality of the fish produced.
Challenges in Commercially Farming Fish
The ocean covers two-thirds of our planet’s surface and, if managed correctly, represents a huge potential for a nutrient-rich food source for our growing global population. As wild fish stocks are increasingly threatened by the world’s rapidly changing economic, political, and environmental conditions as well as overfishing, the production of farmed seafood is a valuable alternative.
A particular limitation to the commercial production of farmed seafood is that they are not safeguarded from changing oceanic conditions due to the use of fish oil from wild-caught fish as an ingredient in the feed. The problem with using wild-caught fish oil is twofold. First, this is a limited resource and should be used prudently. The second issue is that as we understand more about how marine contaminants build up through food chains, health organisations are reducing how marine contaminants build up through food chains, and health organisations are reducing the contaminants allowed in fish destined for consumption. Pollution in the water can make its way into wild fish populations used for oil production. When this oil is used in aquaculture feed, the contaminants are transferred to the seafood, from which the contaminants are transferred to people consuming them.
Developing a Viable Solution
To reduce the use of fish oil as a feed ingredient, BioMar has been leading the work on a more sustainable replacement that decreases the inclusion of marine contaminants present in the oceans. Using an algal-derived oil (taken directly from algae), BioMar produces a more sustainable aquafeed that promotes the development of omega-3 fatty acids, growth, fish health, and product quality.
BioMar reports that their use of fish oil in aquafeed has reduced in recent years. Several factors have contributed to this, including tightening regulations on marine contaminants and increased scarcity of fish oil, which also relates to cost. However, fish oil has high natural levels of omega-3-rich fatty acids, specifically, eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA), which promote fish health and performance. This means farmers using feeds enriched with fish oil produce fish with higher natural levels of omega-3 fatty acids.
Therefore, any potential replacement for fish oil in aquafeed needs to provide just as many benefits to be worth including in the feed. BioMar’s solution, through the work of Dr Kyla Zatti and the research team, is to use algal oil as a replacement for the fish oil, as these should provide the same benefits of the EPA and DHA present in fish oil necessary for healthy fish whilst also being more sustainable and providing increased food safety for human consumption.
Investigating Algal Oil as an Alternative
To test the effects of different balances of fish oil and algal oil in enriching the feed of farmed salmon, 1,020 salmon were evenly distributed amongst 12 sea cages at the LetSea Aquaculture Research Station in Dønna, Norway. The health of the salmon was monitored throughout the year, as were the temperature, oxygen levels, and salinity (saltiness) of the water.
Before the trial began, the oil sources and ten fish from the fish stock were sampled to determine the baseline levels of fatty acids and contaminants already present. Four different feeds were formulated to see their effect on the salmon, where the first was a control feed made with fish oil and rapeseed oil, the second contained a 50% mix of algal and fish oils, the third was a 100% algal oil mixed with rapeseed oil, and the fourth was a 100% algal mixed with linseed oil instead of rapeseed. Each diet was designed to contain the same balance of proteins, fat, EPA and DHA, and other micronutrients.
Feeds were randomly assigned in triplicates to twelve sea cages, and the salmon monitored for over one year from approximately 500 g to 4 kgs in weight. No differences in the health and welfare of the salmon were found between the different feeds, and the final size of the fish was fairly consistent over the twelve pens. The survival rate throughout the duration of the feeding period across the different feeds was 94%. She suggests that increasing the DHA levels in the feed could have beneficial effects on salmon health and further decrease the mortality rate. As an added benefit, the salmon preferred eating the algal feed over the purely fish oil feeds.
At the end of the trial, the effects of the different feeds on fish fatty acid levels, contaminant levels, and fillet quality were investigated. When the contaminant levels were compared in fish fed with algal oil against fish oil mixes, she found that fish provided algal feedstock had significantly lower contaminant levels than those receiving feeds with fish oil. Additionally, the switch from fish-based to algal oils maintained the overall levels of beneficial fatty acids in the fish. The difference in the two vegetable oils changed the balance of fatty acids in the fish, as expected, but didn’t affect overall fish health or performance.
The quality of the fillets was also not impacted by the change in the feed. Previous research suggested that using vegetable oils low in EPA and DHA could lead to some discolouration in the salmon flesh, but found no evidence of this in Dr Zatti’s samples. This suggests that while contaminant levels could be reduced by using certain fish oils, this could increase demand for an already limited resource.
The research performed by Dr Zatti and the research team at BioMar, together with the strategic collaboration with Corbion, has shown that the complete replacement of fish oils with algal oils in aquafeed is highly promising. Using algal oils benefits both sustainability and food safety whilst not impacting the health of the fish or the quality of the final product. As algal oils are already commercialised and ready for use, it seems the time is right for an algal revolution in aquaculture farming techniques.
MEET THE RESEARCHER
Dr Kyla Zatti
Research and Development scientist
Dr Kyla Zatti is a sustainable marine nutrition specialist in the R&D department of BioMar based in Norway. She gained her PhD in 2013 in Animal Science from the University of Saskatchewan, with her thesis ‘Strategies to increase highly-unsaturated n-3 fatty acids in rainbow trout fed vegetable oils’. Following this, Dr Zatti has undertaken significant roles in academia and industry. Her research interests and expertise are dedicated to studying aquaculture feed to improve fish health and fillet quality. She is currently driving advances in the replacement of fish oils used in aquaculture feeds with sustainable algal-based oils. In addition to publishing key papers on her research, Dr Zatti has presented her work at aquaculture and nutrition conferences worldwide.
Dr Zatti would like to thank her fellow colleagues Monica Juarez Ceballos, Victoria Valdenegro Vega, and Vegard Denstadli from BioMar for their support and input throughout the duration of the research and in writing the article discussed here. Further thanks are extended to Corbion for their long-term collaboration with BioMar and the staff at LetSea, who conducted the trial and helped with all the samplings.
KM Zatti, MJ Ceballos, VV Vega, V Denstadli, Full replacement of fish oil with algae oil in farmed Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) – Debottlenecking omega 3, 2023, Aquaculture, 574, 739653. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aquaculture.2023.739653
REPUBLISH OUR ARTICLES
We encourage all formats of sharing and republishing of our articles. Whether you want to host on your website, publication or blog, we welcome this. Find out more
Creative Commons Licence (CC BY 4.0)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
What does this mean?
Share: You can copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format
Adapt: You can change, and build upon the material for any purpose, even commercially.
Credit: You must give appropriate credit, provide a link to the license, and indicate if changes were made.
MORE ARTICLES YOU MAY LIKE
Stroke is a leading cause of disability and death. Despite extensive research and the huge burden on patients and healthcare systems, treatments are sadly limited and new treatments are slow to emerge. To better understand why so many promising drugs that have worked in animal and laboratory studies failed to show the same benefits in human clinical trials, Dr Elise Van Breedam from the University of Antwerp reviewed current research methods. Her review points to the potential for human-based 3D models to bridge the gap between animal studies and human patients.
Professor Andres De Los Reyes – Professor Elizabeth Talbott | Transforming Youth Mental Health Through Evidence-based Assessment
Youth mental health in the USA is in crisis, having steadily worsened over the past ten years. To tackle this crisis, we have to understand it. Evidence-based assessment is key to this understanding. Professor Andres De Los Reyes at the University of Maryland and Professor Elizabeth Talbott at William and Mary lead the study of mental health assessment designed to advance outcomes for all children and youth.
Monitoring a patient’s breathing closely is vital to medical care. However, it comes with a whole set of challenges in young children and those with certain medical conditions. Dr Thomas Shaffer and Dr Tariq Rahman from the Nemours Children’s Hospital, Delaware, USA, work together to develop novel technologies to address this issue and drive better outcomes for their younger patients.
Our planet is in peril. Threats such as climate change, habitat destruction, and pollution are contributing to the loss of species at alarming rates. Protecting biodiversity and enhancing ecosystem resilience relies on protecting evolutionary processes at the scale of individuals, species, populations, and ecosystems. Genetic data is a vital component for achieving this, and yet, a significant gap between conservation geneticists and other scientists, conservation practitioners, and policy-makers hinders knowledge-sharing. Dr Francine Kershaw from the Natural Resources Defense Council, USA, has been helping to spearhead a highly collaborative effort to bridge the gap and enhance conservation efforts.