Dr Ramez Labib – Dr Lisa Hoffman | Evaluating the Environmental Impact of Personal Care Products: The Eco-Innovation Ranking Method

Dec 15, 2023 | Earth & Environmental Sciences

Like many industries, the manufacture of personal care items such as beauty products is increasingly embracing sustainable practices. Dr Ramez Labib and Dr Lisa Hoffman at Avon Products Inc. in the USA have developed an eco-innovation ranking method to support the early stages of product design. Their semi-automated tool is unique in combining a wide range of measures from ecological risk assessment and life cycle assessment to comprehensively assess the environmental impact of products that end up as wastewater.

Sustainable Practice and Personal Care Products

Sustainable practice is increasingly being implemented across different industries. The vast industry dedicated to manufacturing personal care items (such as hair care products, fragrances, and cosmetics) is no exception. There is particular interest in the development of new processes and products with reduced environmental impact, and this is known as eco-innovation.

Many formulated personal care products end up ‘down-the-drain’ as wastewater due to being rinsed off, in the case of shampoo, for example. This means that the aquatic environment (rivers, lakes, oceans, and so on) and the water-dependent species, including fish, plants, and microorganisms that reside there, are vulnerable to potentially toxic and hazardous effects of end-of-life products.

Assessing Environmental Impact

To support eco-innovation, product designers need to be able to evaluate the environmental impact of their products. Two widely used techniques are ecological risk assessment and life cycle assessment. Critical to both is green chemistry, the field of chemical engineering focussed on eliminating (or at least reducing) the use and generation of hazardous substances.

Ecological risk assessment is predominantly used for regulatory decision-making and by some governments to restrict the ingredients used in personal care products. When this happens, companies need to quickly reformulate their product or stop selling it altogether.

Life cycle assessment is the internationally standardised approach to assessing environmental impact. This comprehensive evaluation is time-consuming and resource-intensive to complete but provides more detailed and broader insights into the potential ecological impacts of a product. As such, there is increasing pressure on companies to adopt this approach in their assessments of personal care products. In an effort to develop ‘greener’ product ranges, some companies have been proactive in ascertaining the end-of-life impacts of all the ingredients in their products and not just fragrance compounds and active ingredients as typically undertaken.

The Need for a New Environmental Assessment Tool

Dr Ramez Labib and Dr Lisa Hoffman at Avon Products Inc. in the USA saw the need to be able to obtain comprehensive data via both ecological risk and life cycle assessment during product design to help companies minimise the potentially adverse environmental impacts.

However, a major challenge to this is that personal care products are made from thousands of different ingredients and life cycle data are missing for many of these. Furthermore, at the early stages of the design process, assessments have to rely on what is known about the key chemical properties of the ingredients and foreseeable product use.

Dr Labib and Dr Hoffman worked with Dr Jennifer Saxe (EcoSafety & Sustainability Inc., USA) to develop a new environmental assessment tool incorporating components from both ecological risk assessment and life cycle assessment to support the early design of down-the-drain products. A key aim was to help minimise the risk of new products being reformulated due to regulatory changes in the future.

Selection of Measures: Potential Impact Indicators

The scientists started by reviewing the scientific literature and regulatory models in the public domain to ascertain the potential impact indicators currently available. They ensured their selection of measurements included all ecological risk and life cycle assessment scales that could feasibly be incorporated into the new tool.

The next step was to identify distinct substance classes requiring dedicated and specific environmental assessment. This was achieved by taking representative personal care products, such as shampoos and make-up, and examining the ingredients. The most common ingredient type was classed as ‘non-polymer organic substances’ used either individually or with other similar compounds, and was chosen by the scientists for the initial development of their tool.

The potential impact indicators selected by the researchers include the ecological toxicity during end-of-life exposures, the potential for ground-level photochemical ozone (smog) formation, direct greenhouse gas emissions from the use of the personal care product, and depletion of scarce mineral resources. The concept of ‘persistence’ was included as an independent potential impact indicator, although not technically an environmental impact, in line with the approach taken by Regulators as a proxy measure for exposure and multiple impacts. The aim of this approach is to try to account for complex and unexpected ecosystem impacts that cannot be ascertained on the basis of the extant literature.

The Eco-Innovation Ranking Method

The semi-automated spreadsheet gathers and processes environmental impact data for ingredients and combines the data to produce a single rank value ranging from 1 (best) to 10 (worst) for each ingredient. The tool allows end users to change potential impact indicators as science progresses and priorities change. The scientists illustrated the use of the model with ten shampoos and nine make-up products to confirm its ability to differentiate among formulas.

Application and Implications

Although the scientists have focussed on personal care products, the eco-innovation ranking method can be applied to all down-the-drain products. Importantly, the weighting factors can be readily altered to fit sustainability goals as they emerge and evolve.

The eco-innovation ranking method is unique in combining to promote sustainability at the early product design stage approaches to support early stages of product design. This work will help companies to measure and achieve sustainability objectives, and contribute towards meeting the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals to more effectively manage chemicals throughout their lifecycle and minimise their adverse environmental impacts.

SHARE

DOWNLOAD E-BOOK

REFERENCE

https://doi.org/10.33548/SCIENTIA973

MEET THE RESEARCHERS


Ramez Labib, PhD, MBA, DABT, ERT
Senior Director, Toxicology
Avon Products Inc.
Suffern, NY
USA

Dr Ramez Labib obtained his PhD (Biomedical Sciences in Pharmacology and Toxicology) in 2002 at the University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey, and an MBA at the New Jersey Institute of Technology in 2012. In 2009, he became a Diplomat of the American Board of Toxicology (recertified in 2019) and in 2014 was recognised as a European Registered Toxicologist. He is a full member of the Society of Toxicology, the Society of Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry, and the Mid-Atlantic Chapter of the Society of Toxicology. In his role as Senior Director, Toxicology at Avon, Dr Labib oversees a large team of safety professionals and liaises with R&D professionals to drive innovation.


Lisa Hoffman, PhD
Lead of Toxicology and Clinical Safety (Senior Manager)
Avon Products Inc.
Suffern, NY
USA

Dr Lisa Hoffman obtained her PhD in Pharmaceutical Sciences at St. John’s University (New York) in 2015. She has been a European Registered Toxicologist since 2022, is a member of the Society of Toxicology (SOT), the Mid-Atlantic Regional Chapter of SOT (MASOT), and since 2010, a member of the MASOT Education and Outreach Committee. Dr Hoffman re-joined Avon in 2019 as the Manager of Toxicology and Clinical Safety and is currently the Lead of Toxicology and Clinical Safety (Senior Manager) where she leads a team of toxicologists to ensure the safety of consumer products in all areas of cosmetics, fragrances, and toiletries

KEY COLLABORATORS

Dr Jennifer K. Saxe, EcoSafety & Sustainability Inc.

FUNDING

Avon Products International funded this work.

FURTHER READING

JK Saxe, L Hoffman, R Labib, Method to incorporate green chemistry principles in early-stage product design for sustainability: case studies with personal care products, Green Chemistry, 2022, 24, 4969–4980. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/D2GC00842D

REPUBLISH OUR ARTICLES

We encourage all formats of sharing and republishing of our articles. Whether you want to host on your website, publication or blog, we welcome this. Find out more

Creative Commons Licence (CC BY 4.0)

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. Creative Commons License

What does this mean?

Share: You can copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format

Adapt: You can change, and build upon the material for any purpose, even commercially.

Credit: You must give appropriate credit, provide a link to the license, and indicate if changes were made.

SUBSCRIBE NOW


FOLLOW US

MORE ARTICLES YOU MAY LIKE

Professor John Freebairn | Living in Disaster-Prone Areas: The Need for Informed Decision-Making

Professor John Freebairn | Living in Disaster-Prone Areas: The Need for Informed Decision-Making

Exploring the complexities of residing in disaster-prone areas is challenging for individuals, businesses, and governments. Professor John Freebairn of the University of Melbourne is shedding light on this process, and notes that the benefits of living in disaster-prone areas often outweigh the potential risks. As governments intervene with financial incentives, infrastructure development, and regulatory measures, finding an appropriate balance between short-term relief and long-term resilience is crucial. Professor Freebairn considers the roles of government, information, insurance strategies, and subsidy consequences.

Dr Amílcar Antonio Barreto | Examining the Symbolic Use of Two Flags by Christian Nationalists

Dr Amílcar Antonio Barreto | Examining the Symbolic Use of Two Flags by Christian Nationalists

While individual national identities are typically conveyed using a single flag, some nationalists choose to express their identity with two flags. For instance, Christian nationalists in the USA and South Korea have started flying the Israeli flag beside their country’s national flag at right-wing Christian rallies or outside their homes. Dr Amílcar Antonio Barreto and HyungJin Kim, two researchers at Northeastern University, have recently carried out a study exploring the symbolic meaning of this double flag use among Christian nationalists.

Dr Brenda O’Neill | New Insights into Feminist Perspectives on Banning the Face Veil

Dr Brenda O’Neill | New Insights into Feminist Perspectives on Banning the Face Veil

In recent years, many European countries have introduced bans that limit or prohibit the use of religious face veils, which include the burqa and niqab. Dr Brenda O’Neill worked with colleagues to examine the role of feminist arguments amongst non-Muslim women in Quebec on the acceptability of wearing the niqab in public spaces. This work explored some additional attitudes underpinning these arguments, identifying how these also shape the diverse beliefs of Canadian women.

Professor Richard Collins – Dr Jintai Li | Project Super Soaker: Investigating High-altitude Polar Ice Clouds with Rockets

Professor Richard Collins – Dr Jintai Li | Project Super Soaker: Investigating High-altitude Polar Ice Clouds with Rockets

Phenomena in the upper atmosphere are difficult to study for several reasons – some rarely form, others are difficult to see, and all are incredibly high up. Polar Mesospheric Clouds (PMCs) are no exception, forming at around 80 kilometres up into the sky, only under specific atmospheric conditions, and only visible to the naked eye during twilight. PMCs are also called noctilucent or ‘night-shining’ clouds, as they appear to glow in the summer nighttime sky. Professor Richard Collins from the University of Alaska Fairbanks is using rockets to seed these clouds, allowing better investigations of both PMCs and the effects of space traffic on our upper atmosphere.